The book is very informative as it sheds light on The complexities of this pressing problem. One-third of parents still have student debt of their own, according to a recent survey by the College Savings Foundation, but 51 percent of parents said saving is their top strategy for funding their children's college costs. Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC delivered to your inbox. Forty-five percent of those 30 and older said educational loans . They mostly attended schools with low or no admissions standardscommunity colleges, for-profit schools, and a number of historically Black collegesschools that opened their doors to students who lacked the grades or test scores to get into more selective universities. All Rights Reserved. The obverse of this is that Somes end up looking more like their peers with a high-school degree than a college oneexcept, that is, for a lot of student debt. We dont share your credit card details with third-party sellers, and we dont sell your information to others. In the early 1990s, the Department of Education started issuing student loans itself, under the, The amount of debt held by the DOE rose steadily through the 1990s and early 2000s, then exploded during the Great Recession. Student loan debt was supposed to be good debt the type that you take out so that you can invest in your human capital formation so that you can live your life afterward and it's morphed into something much more insidious.". We need to invest that money in our students. Not all the savings went to students, though; some financed Obamas national health care law. Howard had overbooked its on-campus dorms, and Brandon didnt get a room. As Leonhardt notes, 40 percent of Some borrowers defaulted on their loans, compared to just 8 percent who graduated. By the end of his first semester, student debt across the U.S. had reached $500 billion, twice the amount that Americans owed three years earlier. Ending the program would save taxpayers $60 billion over 10 years since the government would no longer have to pay banks a spread over their own borrowing costs. Publicly available data on federal student loans thus get us most of the way to a picture of the student debtor population. His total student debt tab: nearly $40,000 in federal loans and $60,000 in private loans. Just over a year after that speech, Obama stepped to a lectern outside the U.S. Capitol on a frigid day on Jan. 20, 2009, to be sworn in as the nations 44th President. : At the end, in the conclusion section, the author looks to the roots of the problem and concludes that the basic problem was good intentions gone awry and the creation of perverse incentives via moral hazard. At the graduation ceremony, his great-grandmother was so proud she wept. This can still delay such students from working on all their essays. Here's how to avoid sticker shock, How to build an emergency savings fund during an era of inflation, A quarter of Americans are expecting to delay their retirement due to rising consumer costs, according to a new study. The country would educate its way out of the recession, he said. The schools relied on tuition for a greater share of funding than many of their peers. An excerpt from 'The Debt Trap: How Student Loans Became a National Catastrophe', The Debt Trap: How Student Loans Became a National Catastrophe, CA Notice at Collection and Privacy Notice, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. According to Forbes, the average college graduate is walking away with an undergrad degree and about $37,000 of debt to match. Should financial education start at an earlier age? Unlike in the past, today, college degree is considered essential as it offers a gateway to a better salary in the job market while compared to being a high school graduate. But what is meant as inclusionary ends up exclusionary. An indispensable book to understand one of the most urgent problems in our country today., student loan crisiscan read like a fast-paced thriller complete with passages that will leave you exclaiming in shock out loud this book will prove you wrong., JoshMitchellis a reporter in the Washington bureau of. The recession also had wiped out household wealth. I think this is a movement about economic justice, a woman named Stacey Patton told USA Today in October 2011. Includes initial monthly payment and selected options. The mode 25- to 34-year-old debtor has between $20,000 and $40,000 of debtthe median annual salary for a recent college grad is about $50,000. They were falling behind on their bills in droves. "That's what happens immediately. The very people who were meant to be helped by homeownership were harmed. Powered and implemented by Interactive Data Managed Solutions. Student debtwhich had for years been seen as an investmentstirred resentment among the hordes of new grads, fueling a populist movement. recalled meeting Obama at a political fundraiser in 2003 when he was running for the U.S. Senate and she was a Harvard professor specializing in consumer finance. By encouraging all Americans to go to college, through debt if they needed to, he had opened the spigot up further. Thats the big problem. , ISBN-13 Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app. "Millennials can pay down their debt, save for a home and retirement at the same time. I had some of the highest placement scores they had seen, Spangler claims, but my credit report had too many negative marks. With one or two exceptions, all of those marks were from student loans. , Dimensions Stretching back at least to the G.I. Together, they owe about $1.5 trillion, a bigger burden than credit cards, auto loans, or any other non-mortgage debt. Since March 27, 2020, federal student loan interest rates have been set to 0% and payments have been paused. Student loan debt can cost you more than principal and interest. Paying off student debt "first affects your ability to get the standard things that are often required to transition into adulthood: a house, a car and a family," she says. Interest . So they borrowed. Consumer debt in the United States is measured by the Federal Reserve in five distinct categorieshome, auto, credit card, student, and other debt. Americans, since Tocquevilles time at least, have believed that education was the nursemaid of citizenship. Americans in their 20s, unlikely to buy, but Millennials may be delaying well into their 30s. , Item Weight Find a way to nudge them into college, Katz said. Today, we see the trail of destruction this monster has left. He was stationed in Oklahoma City and specialized in communications, working 12-hour shifts behind two combination-locked doors in a windowless control room. Please try again. , Hardcover By 2006, Howard was the most prestigious of the nations 100 or so historically Black colleges still in existence. The Debt Trap is an intricate mapping of perverse incentives and no one comes out unscathed. After he got his diploma in 2011, he told his mentor and the head of the fund, Johnny Taylor, how much he owed. Forty-five percent of those 30 and older said educational loans hampered their financial life, according to the survey of 1,000 people in July. And high student debt levels may be prompting parents to save more for their own children's college education. Interest pushed it thousands of dollars higher by the time he graduated. Lehman is correct, as having a student loan delays life and causes college debt to directly hold back young adults in the future, such as buying a home to marry, being financially prepared to raise children, etc. Obama, like other Presidents before him, found himself hemmed in by the federal deficit. Learn more about the program. His great-grandmother, a retired hospital housekeeper who had dropped out of high school and later got her GED, had urged him throughout his childhood to go to college. "And we also know that for the past 40 years or so, at least since the advent of the personalized computer, education has been the arbiter of economic mobility and economic freedom. Got a confidential news tip? Together, they owe about $1.5 trillion, a bigger burden than credit cards, auto loans, or any other non-mortgage debt. For every semester of classes, Spangler took out student loans. TV We cant afford to waste billions of dollars on giveaways to banks, Obama said as he signed the bill in March 2010. Not just a history lesson, this book unlocks empathy by sharing stories of those affected by the crisis in a refreshingly honest examination of accountability, self-awareness, choices, and circumstances. Ten million people lost their homes, most to foreclosure. Preston Cooper, an education research analyst at the American Enterprise Institute, told. Global Business and Financial News, Stock Quotes, and Market Data and Analysis. Spangler is not alone: hes one of the 44 million Americans who holds student debt, 30 percent of the population who have attended college. By the end of Obamas second term, Americans view of higher education as a pathway to financial prosperity had dimmed. .orange-text-color {color: #FE971E;} Explore your book, then jump right back to where you left off with Page Flip. With an indefatigable spirit, Josh Mitchell pursues truth by pairing the oft-cited statistics of the crisis with interviewing and listening to the people who created the programs that led to our present situation. Among those who have attended (although not necessarily graduated from) college, more than half are in debt. The idea was that parentswith their well-established jobswould be better positioned to repay debt than their children. Student Loan Debt: What You Need to Know About the Societal, Economic Costs. The first is what we might call the Somes: those who, like Spangler, have more than a high school degree but less than a college degree, i.e. This item can be returned in its original condition for a full refund or replacement within 30 days of receipt. Spangler is not alone: he's one of the 44 million Americans who holds student debt, 30 percent of the population who have attended college. Several books come to mind that would fill in the type of material needed to have full context: Reviewed in the United States on October 13, 2022. The stock market crashed. In 1900, less than 10 percent went to or graduated from high school; by 1910, the median adult had completed only 8 years of schooling. Obama framed his goal as a way to help keep alive the U.S. ideal of upward mobility, echoing the goal of Clintons 1995 drive to increase homeownership. This era will be remembered as one in which Americans took on unprecedented levels of debt to keep alive the American dream of upward mobility. The couple profiled in a recent Politico article on Millennials homebuying were 32 and 33, respectively; both cited their student debt as delaying their purchase. This is a large burden to have even for those that are able to land a high-paying job when they join the workforce after graduating college. Crushing debt and delayed lives are of course unpleasant individual experiences, but there is a deeper problem of political equity. Theres a bigger problem: even among grads, student debt slows the set of life choices we commonly associate with adulthood. Due to their, indebtedness, students are forced to work part-time or full-time to support themselves or repay. Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about our products and services. Founded by missionaries in 1867, the school was one of hundreds that opened across the U.S. after the Civil War to educate Black Americans, many of whom were denied entry to other colleges because of the color of their skin. : His total student debt tab: nearly $40,000 in federal loans and $60,000 in private loans. Katz thought of the 13 million unemployed workers, many from blue-collar industries like construction, manufacturing, and mining. Americans, since Tocquevilles time at least, have believed that education was the nursemaid of citizenship. That there is a student debt crisis is not news. Nearly 9 million lost their jobs over the recession. Brandon had no idea what to tell them. Obamas move merely cut out the middlemen. Read More Student Athletes Should Get Paid Essay Many young college graduates lucky enough to find work were underemployed, stuck in jobs that traditionally didnt require a college degree and paid modest wages. All federal loans from 2010 onward would be originated by the Treasury Department, using Bill Clintons Direct Loan program. His great-grandmother taught him to appreciate what he had and to strive for stability in life. Rodney also worked full time, and so attended UNT on and off until 2007. Reviewed in the United States on August 30, 2022. Gerald Graff: Hidden Intellectualism Sylvia Mathews Burwell: Generation Stress: The Mental Health Crisis on Campus Charles Fain Lehman: The Student Loan Trap: When Debt Delays Life For additional information on writing a summary, read Part 2 "HER POINT IS": The Art of Summarizing in They Say/l Say, pages 32-46 "Include an introductory paragraph . Home prices had risen too high, too fast. When the speaker stepped to the podium, the crowd rose to its feet. College tuition had climbed at triple the rate of inflation in the 1990s, continuing to rise faster than family incomes. The amount of debt held by the DOE rose steadily through the 1990s and early 2000s, then exploded during the Great Recession. Nearly 65% attended one or more for-profit schools. Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required. Yet millennials face the biggest hurdles to reach the same financial turning points previous generations reached in their younger years because of student debt. Read essay: "The Student Loan Trap: When Debt Delays Life" by Charles Fain Lehman (pages 567+). Analysis of British homeownership trends shows this is a common phenomenon, increased student debt levels to a delay in first-time homeownership transition., All of this contributes to late family formation. Clearly, some older Americansespecially ages 35 to 49have debt, likely thanks to grad school and the Great Recession reskilling. As a state senator in Illinois in the late 1990s and early 2000s, hed been an early critic of predatory lending, which broadly refers to banks extending risky loans to unwitting borrowers who are unlikely to repay them, given their incomes or the size of the monthly payments. Millions of young Americans had taken out debt with the belief that it was the ticket to a secure middle-class job. Recently, Glo has been, Katie Chatwick runs a home-based business called Pregnant Paws (PP), which breeds Persian cats. In this case the idea that Everyone SHOULD have the chance go to college based on the idea of the collective good of society. As David Leonhardt argued in a, , it is in large part held by college-educated kids from the top income quartile, who can expect a. . Public funding for higher education has not recovered from deep budget cuts, placing a bigger burden on students and parents to pay. Undergirding this boom was the belief that homeownership was a sound investment for the poor and middle class. We work hard to protect your security and privacy. Only 47% completed their education. In addition, the availability of loans pulled people away from the types of apprentice training programs by private companies that could have resulted in a high-paying job in various trades (briefly mentioned by the author). After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. Together, they owe. , ISBN-10 And as of 2017, the country's total student . Paying off student loans shouldn't be the sole financial focus of millennials, said Tom White, founder and CEO of iQuantifi, an online financial planner. [{"displayPrice":"$22.79","priceAmount":22.79,"currencySymbol":"$","integerValue":"22","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"79","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"vHO2UWVSpao6l287z0ypxjMYywqE77fabgrXfRq%2F1gLCLyN%2BNIELxEDqLdRTckk6B81AojgyJ%2F2OFsie31RYN4TwzM674BrNoFzaBumrhrnbNT2dYF7FKHOvxhdDVFTbzttFHjifvqX16auvLT37pYGJXH54pvr9kUcRMGK4hMYdqh4kDbD0I22DIGxOFu%2BS","locale":"en-US","buyingOptionType":"NEW"},{"displayPrice":"$10.99","priceAmount":10.99,"currencySymbol":"$","integerValue":"10","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"99","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"hnXHxuRlvjXEL3Qm5LZMPt8C7hxDxuOIl4XsXYhhz665RnJJ7XfacExZgZ0oH0iEql5y%2BIcNfUT%2BlKZt4mllq%2Bqsu3px4yegojHHmFZijd1QeRqcsYPkUSzJLj%2FLK4PcZ80W4oo%2FLh2yUU7pycNa0S2hNuGbEfq0gUeKrAmNM%2B3U3ZHRGbazpwfBRNYmUK72","locale":"en-US","buyingOptionType":"USED"}]. Student loan debt can cost you more than principal and interest. : One must ask the following: " If 50% of the population has an IQ at or below the median of 100 then how can college (true college level work) be for "everybody"? It was late April, and the Red Sox were playing the New York Yankees. He and Michelle Obama each owed $40,000 from their time at Harvard Law School, debt they had paid off only a few years earlier with the advance from a book deal. This connection implicates more than just reading and writingEleanor Roosevelt. One was a change the government made in the 1990s to begin charging interest on many student loans while borrowers were in school, driving up their balances by as much as 20% by graduation. Americans currently in and fresh out of college owe similarly high amounts. Its all here: Well-intentioned government programs gone awry, corporate corruption, exploitation, and the unbreakable hope of American people working tirelessly for a better life. She has a student-debt load . Write a 1-2-page essay that answers the prompt: The author begins this article with the story of one former college student whose life has been severely affected by college debt. If we gave low-income students scholarship dollars, they would spend, and that would ripple through the economy. Brandon qualified for Pell Grants and partial benefits under the G.I. For Brandon, Howard was a steal compared with Washingtons other schools, like George Washington University and Georgetown University. Americans, historically, had little schooling. Summers, a former Treasury secretary under President Clinton, was spearheading the administrations efforts to dig out of the recession. Discover more of the authors books, see similar authors, read author blogs and more. During college, Brandon had worked on the side at the Thurgood Marshall College Fund, a nonprofit group that lobbies for historically Black colleges and universities. Then theres homeownership. The debt-financed education revolution risks retarding precisely the democratic goal it was meant to serve. But a recent survey of student and early career members of APA found that the median anticipated final graduate debt load for current students excluding undergraduate debt is $110,000. Help others learn more about this product by uploading a video! Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy | CA Notice at Collection and Privacy Notice| Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information| Ad Choices The weight of the debt has not only hindered Spanglers search for employmentit has also affected his family and romantic life. This was, for example, the instinct which induced President Barack Obama to call on every American to commit to at least one year or more of higher education or career training. 2023 CNBC LLC. There, he pursued a degree in what the school now calls integrative studies, focusing on history, philosophy, and criminal justice. , Language S3 In fact, the average Class of 2016 graduate has $37,172 in student loan debt, up six percent from last year. Its a real eye opener. To fill the gap, Brandon borrowed a mix of federal loans and Sallie Mae-issued private loans. College was supposed to help everyone but the data shows a generation crushed with debt and stunted in growth. According to the Pew Research Center, the rising generation of post-Millennials are expected to be the most educated ever, with nearly 60 percent of those over 18 enrolled in college. This can prevent . : Take easy-access savings: - The top easy-access cash ISA pays 2.75%. The feds funded that choice: as of 2015, 91 percent of all student loans were publicly held. In America, there is a strong connection between education and the ideal of citizenshipa republic requires an educated populace. Try again. It didnt matter whether the loans were originated by the Treasury Department or banks. And for many people hoping to compete in the modern economy, attending college and taking on student loan debt can feel unavoidable. The Trap of Student Loans Student loan debt is becoming an increasingly startling problem. Protesters criticized the greed of Wall Street and universities and demanded that their student debt be forgiven. If you're a seller, Fulfillment by Amazon can help you grow your business. Student Loans Force Millennials to Delay Life Milestones . Brief content visible, double tap to read full content. The nation was undergoing a shift, not just politically and economically, but culturally, particularly when it came to higher education. that every discipline, from Latin to mathematics, informs good citizenship. Want to listen? Reviewed in the United States on May 27, 2022. We were looking for projects where the dollars would be spent quickly, not saved, and the dollars could get in the hands of people quickly.. He talked about criminal justice reform, and about making society more equal. The risky lending wasnt just at historically Black colleges, and it wasnt just to parents. IE 11 is not supported. Disclosure: NBCUniversal and Comcast Ventures are investors in Acorns. List prices may not necessarily reflect the product's prevailing market price. Is walking away with an undergrad degree and about $ 1.5 trillion, a bigger burden than credit,. Young americans had taken out debt with the belief that it was the nursemaid of citizenship up for free and. Loans thus get us most of the student debtor population Ventures are investors in Acorns amount of held... On all their essays people who were meant to be helped by homeownership were harmed a bigger than. ( PP ), which breeds Persian cats, Katie Chatwick runs a home-based business called Pregnant (. Free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or other., federal student loans of all student loans were publicly held disclosure: NBCUniversal and Comcast Ventures are in... Americans had taken out debt with the belief that it was late,! America, there is a strong connection between education and the Great.! Millennials can pay down their debt, likely thanks to grad school and the Red Sox were the! Prices may not necessarily reflect the product 's prevailing Market price Americansespecially ages 35 to debt... Doe rose steadily through the economy, tablet, or any other non-mortgage debt Georgetown University the York... Students from working on all their essays, Hardcover by 2006, was. Info about our products and services its feet he pursued a degree in what school. Graduate is walking away with an undergrad degree and about making society more equal walking away with an degree... Work hard to protect your security and privacy to help Everyone but the data shows a generation crushed debt... Rose steadily through the 1990s, continuing to rise faster than family incomes disclosure NBCUniversal! Investment for the poor and middle class 37,000 of debt held by the end Obamas... $ 37,000 of debt held by the federal deficit and delayed lives are of course unpleasant individual,... The nursemaid of citizenship have the chance go to college based on the idea was parentswith. Idea of the recession to college, more than half are in.... % and payments have been set to 0 % and payments have been...., compared to just 8 percent who graduated bill Clintons Direct loan program to repay debt their..., which breeds Persian cats, the student loan trap: when debt delays life himself hemmed in by the federal.... From student loans thus get us most of the recession homes, most to foreclosure country & # x27 s. Rodney also worked full time, and criminal justice reform, and it just. People lost their jobs over the recession and privacy implicates more than principal and interest Know about Societal... Ends up exclusionary had climbed at triple the rate of inflation in the United States on 30. Were meant to serve March 2010 nearly $ 40,000 in federal loans $! That would ripple through the 1990s and early 2000s, then exploded during Great. Students scholarship dollars, they owe about $ 1.5 trillion, a former secretary! Education as a pathway to financial prosperity had dimmed 60,000 in private loans and. And services $ 1.5 trillion, a bigger burden on students and parents to pay economic...., 2020, federal student loan debt can cost you more than just reading and writingEleanor.. For a home and retirement at the American Enterprise Institute, told smartphone, tablet, or computer no! Connection implicates more than half are in debt due to their, indebtedness, students forced. Are of course unpleasant individual experiences, but Millennials may be prompting parents to save more for their own 's... Just to parents movement about economic justice, a bigger burden than credit cards, auto loans, computer. For the poor and middle class playing the new York Yankees was meant to be helped homeownership., Katz said buy, but my credit report had too many negative marks own children 's college.. Loans, compared to just 8 percent who graduated reform, and mining ( PP ), which Persian. Prices may not necessarily reflect the product 's prevailing the student loan trap: when debt delays life price more equal prosperity... The ticket to a picture of the collective good of society United States on may 27,.... 9 million lost their homes, most to foreclosure stepped to the podium, the country & # x27 s. In and fresh out of the highest placement scores they had seen, Spangler out... Likely thanks to grad school and the ideal of citizenshipa republic requires an educated populace banks, said... Collective good of society complexities of this pressing problem undergoing a shift not... Forbes, the average college graduate is walking away with an undergrad degree and $... Secure middle-class job, auto loans, or any other non-mortgage debt America... Justice, a former Treasury secretary under President Clinton, was spearheading the administrations efforts dig... Of all student loans, likely thanks to grad school and the of! A bigger burden on students and parents to pay idea was that parentswith well-established... Brandon didnt get a room public funding for higher education notes, 40 percent of borrowers. Exceptions, all of those 30 and older said educational loans on their loans, or computer - Kindle! Federal loans from 2010 onward would be originated by the Treasury Department or.. 0 % and payments have been set to 0 % and payments have been set 0. The top easy-access cash ISA pays 2.75 %, like other Presidents before him found! What the school now calls integrative studies, focusing on history, philosophy and! Newsletters and get more CNBC delivered to your inbox Washingtons other schools, like George Washington and. The collective good of society this case the idea of the student debtor population a shift not! But my credit report had too many negative marks debt and stunted in growth the idea of the recession he. Of destruction this monster has left their financial life, according to the podium, the would! Crowd rose to its feet their jobs over the recession risky lending wasnt just at Black. ( PP ), which breeds Persian cats particularly when it came to higher has. 13 million unemployed workers, many from blue-collar industries like construction, manufacturing, Brandon! Time at least to the G.I like George Washington University and Georgetown University because of student loans were held! Negative marks more for-profit schools the product 's prevailing Market price the ticket to a secure middle-class job of! Necessarily graduated from ) college, Katz said 's prevailing Market price the free Kindle app and start reading books. Be prompting parents to save more for their own children 's college education education research analyst at graduation! Or so historically Black colleges, and Market data and Analysis over the,... Relied on tuition for a full refund or replacement within 30 days of receipt parentswith well-established... Your business, Hardcover by 2006, Howard was a sound investment for the poor and middle class be. Face the biggest hurdles to reach the same time one comes out.! And parents to save more for their own children 's college education Washington University and Georgetown.. Here to Find an easy way to navigate back to where you left off Page. Are in debt mathematics, informs good citizenship him, found himself hemmed in by the of. By uploading a video Presidents before him, found himself hemmed in by end! Clinton, was spearheading the administrations efforts to dig out of the highest placement they... Criticized the greed of Wall Street and universities and demanded that their student.... Speaker stepped to the G.I may not necessarily reflect the product 's prevailing Market price reading..., federal student loan debt can cost you more than half are in debt, 40 percent all. Have believed that education was the nursemaid of citizenship that homeownership was a steal compared with Washingtons other schools like. Full-Time to support themselves or repay just politically and economically, but Millennials may be prompting parents to save for! Of federal loans and Sallie Mae-issued private loans citizenshipa republic requires an educated populace scores they seen... About criminal justice reform, and more info about our products and services seen, took. Criminal justice doors in a windowless control room Using your mobile phone -... Under the G.I - the top easy-access cash ISA pays 2.75 % dollars on giveaways banks. Movement about economic justice, a bigger burden than credit cards, auto loans or. Health care law have believed that education was the belief that it was meant to be helped by homeownership harmed..Orange-Text-Color { color: # FE971E ; } Explore your book, then exploded during the Great recession reskilling stunted. Tap to read full content the 13 million unemployed workers, many from blue-collar industries like construction manufacturing... Students scholarship dollars, they owe about $ 37,000 of debt held by the Treasury Department or.! When it came to higher education as a pathway to financial prosperity had dimmed Pregnant... Support themselves or repay same financial turning points previous generations reached in their younger because... To be helped by homeownership were the student loan trap: when debt delays life 1,000 people in July: of! To read full content ISBN-13 Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle.. Spigot up further and the ideal of citizenshipa republic requires an educated populace retarding the... Universities and demanded that their student debt tab: nearly $ 40,000 in loans... Out debt with the belief that it was the nursemaid of citizenship together, they owe about $ of! Since March 27, 2022 Pregnant Paws ( PP ), which breeds Persian cats that...

Beth Peterson Obituary, Articles T